I’ve noticed Bill Kerr’s blogging getting sharper and more critical of late. I’m enjoying the odd attack he launches, backed up with some very useful links and resources. If ever I get to build a faculty, Bill is on my list.
This time Bill has posted about Seymour Papert, refering to his book Mindstorms and his learning theory constructionism – not constructivism!
I don’t see much correlation at all between those ideas and the politically correct nonsense that passes as social constructivist top down curriculum reform over the past few years. In my opinion the whole idea of promoting constructivism in a top down fashion through curriculum statements imposed by a hierarchy are farcical and doomed to failure. Papert was always against centrally imposed curriculum arising out of his basic analysis of how a “society of mind” evolved in each individual.
Like Bill, I wish more people in education refered to Papert. When I was in teacher training I nearly failed a subject for using constructionism (it wasn’t, and as far as I know, still isn’t in the training curriculum of NSW teachers), my lecturer thought I meant to say constructivism. Likewise, when I have sat for interviews and when asked what theories I subscribe to, I have to correct people when they think I mean constructivism when I mean constructionism.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons (Attribution) license.
–>







3 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 6, 2006 at 4:09 am
Bill Kerr
That reminds me of a story from a programmer friend who was asked what design technique he preferred at a job interview – he replied, “extreme programming” (a well established design method)- and noticed some reserve coming back at the use of the word, “extreme” – since then when asked the same question he responds, “agile programming” – it means the same thing but is more acceptable to those in charge
March 6, 2006 at 12:19 pm
Leigh Blackall
Its a shame how name sakes prejudice affects so much of what we do. I would say the name blog has had quite an impact on its formal uptake – hence the renaming to web journal, ePortfolios and the like..
This would be the same for many FLOSS projects like GIMP and Audacity…
May 19, 2008 at 12:28 am
A Belated Response To A Great Post By Sylvia Martinez | Teaching Generation Z
[...] professional practice. (I had never heard of constructionism until I crossed paths with Bill and Leigh Blackall.) I have heard Dr. Trudy Sweeney (part of this Learning Technologies grant) on more than one [...]