I took my subscriptions back into Bloglines today. Google Reader had some nice features, but one key thing it doesn’t have is socially networked links. There are times when I need to quickly share a few feeds with another teacher, fellow student or a friend. This is not easy with Google Reader, but with Bloglines they just view my public Bloglines account and import the feeds into their own account… it’s a bit like Del.icio.us on that count.
Another aspect that Bloglines has over Google Reader is the ability to see who else is subscribed to the feed, and then to look at their feeds. I think this is a useful assessment tool for teachers, a feedback tool for publishers, and a research tool for network surfers.
I saw this shortcoming of Google Reader straight away, but at the time I was willing to go without them for the pleasurable display features of Google Reader. But after about 2 months use, I got used to those novelties and started to really miss the social network features of Bloglines.
Basically, I prefer the simplicity and socially networked aspects of Bloglines. Google Reader thinks a bit too much for me, in its effort to make news reading more seamless. But having a machine think for me is more often than not an annoyance.

4 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 1, 2007 at 11:32 am
Alexander Hayes
Bloglines like del.icio.us rocks.
It’s easy to use and teach. And I dont have to think like a frickin loony to work out what went where.
Seamless machine reader I need to be. I like comment boxes that have BIG text too.
More pub poetry and educator depictions my way
March 1, 2007 at 1:37 pm
Doug Holton
Yeah I don’t like the fancy stuff in Google Reader, like how it forces you to manually scroll through every entry to mark a blog or folder as read. Sometimes there are a ton of old posts reappearing and I just want to skip them.
Also you can’t use the back button.
March 11, 2007 at 11:31 pm
Miguel Guhlin
What are features that would make an RSS reader even better than Bloglines and G-reader?
Maybe we should design our own.
Miguel Guhlin
Around the Corner-MGuhlin.net
http://www.mguhlin.net
March 12, 2007 at 8:47 am
Leigh Blackall
take the best features of both and add them together. Add the ability to mix and present feeds in a new blog - ala suprglue of yahoo pipes and we’re getting really nice then. Ensure that it is usable on mobile phones, and that it is quick and easy to forward stuff on to email. Niether Google or Bloglines do that particularly well. Also, offer a setting where you can switch the reader between local or web based client. And add a few print template options as well!